Moving Large Cohorts Online: A Collaborative Research Journey

Strange Days Indeed!

Over a year into the COVID-19 pandemic, with Zoom now at the heart of our new ‘remote’ lives, it is easy to forget that in March 2020, online teaching and learning was a brand new experience for many staff and students. With little time for planning, the initial pivot to remote teaching and learning was very much an emergency response and far from what we would aspire to in terms of online teaching and learning design. As April and May unfolded, it became clear that the emergency pivot online would continue into the new academic year.

This extended period offered the DCU community an opportunity to move past emergency remote teaching and learning provision, and to conceptualize the student learning experience for the online space in a more considered manner.

While the pedagogical redesign of learning activities continued to be undertaken in an emergency context, there was a little more time to consider the needs of both students and staff. Conversations were happening at local and National level around how best to address these needs as we moved into a second semester of remote teaching and learning. 

Against the background of such conversations, a funding call from the DCU Educational Trust, sparked an idea for a potential research study for Ann Marie Farrell, Lecturer in the School of Special and Inclusive Education.

Having a wealth of experience and expertise in large cohort teaching and learning, Ann Marie was particularly concerned about the implications of the emergency pivot to remote teaching and learning for students and staff in such contexts.

The invitation to get involved in the project was a ‘no-brainer’ for the Teaching Enhancement Unit (TEU) contingent (*Karen Buckley, Mark Glynn, Rob Lowney and Suzanne Stone). As the Unit planned for a second semester supporting staff around remote teaching and learning, insights on the particular challenges of the large cohort context would be invaluable.  Seán Smyth (4th year Bachelor of Education student) completed our research team, adding an incisive student perspective

Meeting the Challenge

Having successfully secured funding for the research project, reality struck! The prospect of fitting an additional piece of work into our schedules at such a demanding time was frankly terrifying.

It was important to the team that the research would offer practical support for DCU staff as we moved into the next academic year, adding the additional challenge of a short timeframe.

Despite these challenges the project structure took shape and the collaborative and supportive team environment enabled the work to progress at the required pace. The purpose of the study was determined as follows:

  • To shed light on the sudden transition of DCU’s large classes (100+ students) from the face-to-face teaching and learning setting to the online environment in March 2020 from the perspectives of staff and students; 
  • To contextualise the findings arising from the examination of the transition referred to above by reviewing relevant literature; and
  • To inform the work (a) of academics in DCU teaching large-class cohorts and (b) of DCU’s academic developers and learning technologists, supporting them in this endeavour, as large programmes and modules move online in the forthcoming academic year.

This three-fold purpose guided our research design and data collection process with data collected from three sources: (1) a rapid, systematised review of relevant literature; 2) surveys of DCU students and staff who experienced the recent pivot of their large classes online; and (3) information relating to the TEU teaching supports provided to staff during the period March-June 2020. The support of the DCU Educational Trust allowed us to outsource the data analysis which would not have been tenable for the team to complete within our short project timeframe. 

Just in Time Sharing

Our research team was committed to publishing guidelines for staff, as soon as possible, to support them in redesigning the large-class learning environment for the 2020/21 academic year. While the full report was not ready for publication, in early September 2020 a set of summary guidelines, drawing on the findings of the research, was collated and circulated to staff within DCU.

Moving Large Face-to-face Classes Online, provided timely guidance for staff across four key aspects of teaching online: curriculum design in the online space; teaching; learning and engagement; and assessment.

The guidance document was structured to offer both immediate and ongoing advice, thus supporting staff in the immediate context and also for online or hybrid contexts that are likely to increase in the future beyond COVID-19. In addition, the research team was committed to sharing the initial findings and guidance document with those teaching and learning in Higher Education beyond the DCU community. The findings were shared at several national and international events from June 2020, and we hope to continue this dissemination in the coming months. 

From Challenge to Opportunity

While the study was borne of challenging times, we feel that the crisis placed a spotlight on teaching and learning and offered us as practitioners in Higher Education an invaluable opportunity to reflect on what constitutes good teaching and learning.  While the focus was on the large cohort teaching context, we feel that the findings can inform practice in all teaching and learning contexts.

The final research report was published in February of this year and the warm response on social media and the engagement statistics have been most rewarding for the research team. Our hope is that this small research project offers some support for those teaching and learning in large cohort contexts, both in the current remote teaching context and into the future, which seems inevitably to include an increased level of remote and hybrid teaching and learning.

*Note: Karen Buckley has since taken up the role of Assistant Professor at the School of Special and Inclusive Education, Institute of Education.

Three New NIDL Research Projects Investigating Online Education in Response to Covid-19

The NIDL team is looking forward to leading and contributing to three new research projects over the next few months investigating how the higher education sector has responded to the Covid-19 global health crisis. Two of the following projects come under the umbrella of Dublin City University’s new dedicated Covid-19 Research and Innovation Hub established in response to the global pandemic. The Hub is leveraging DCU’s research expertise, in collaboration with national and international stakeholders, with a view to developing solutions that can be implemented and deployed within a three to six months time frame.

photo-1516321497487-e288fb19713f

Beyond the Covid Pivot: Towards Transformative Online Learning

The first project led by the NIDL involving a team from the Ideas Lab and Open Education Unit, with the DCU Student Union as an Associate Partner, along with discussions underway with other stakeholders, focuses on the student online learning experience. The basic tenet of the research is that learning online is not the same as learning in a traditional classroom, it requires a different set of skills to master. With the recent pivot to online learning in response to Covid-19, the ability to learn effectively online has never been more important.

UNESCO Covid-19Looking forward we need to develop the capacity of students to become effective online learners. We also need to look back to understand and learn from the experience of students so far. This project will, therefore, develop and conduct research on a ‘Learning How to Learn Online’ MOOC on a major platform to support students as they adapt to a greater focus on learning online in higher education settings.

The study will research students’ experiences and perceptions of barriers to learning online in response to COVID-19. These insights from the key-face of the student learning experience will inform future institutional decision-making, help the sector to better harness the potential of online education, and most importantly provide improved online learning experiences for students.

Moving Large, Face-to-Face Classes Online 

This project led by Dr Ann Marie Farrel in DCU’s Institute of Education, with a significant NIDL contribution from members of the Teaching Enhancement Unit, investigates online teaching in large classes. Since March, teaching usually carried out in the face-to-face context has moved very suddenly online. This has been a particular challenge for those teaching large class cohorts and for the students comprising those cohorts.

photo-1566683777581-1a8051f226c9The overall aim of this project is to inform the practice of (i) academics teaching large groups and (ii) those supporting academics in the large class teaching/learning context as we move forward into the next phase of our response to the requirements for social distancing and more creative and innovation forms of teaching online. 

The move to the online environment since March will be evaluated; data from supports provided since March will be analysed (e.g. support requests, PD workshops and seminars since campus closure) and surveys will be used to gather data on the student and staff experience. The intended outcomes of this project will provide guidance for designing learning experiences in the online context, taking diversity of large classes into account.

An Investigation of Affect in Online Teaching during COVID-19

We Need Your HelpThis internationally focused NIDL project asks how have you been feeling while teaching online? It calls on all higher education educators in Ireland, Europe and globally to share their affective experiences of teaching online in response to the Covid-19 crisis. The research seeks to better understand affective and, in particular, educators’ emotions  during their experiences of teaching online in order to learn valuable lessons and help inform support strategies moving forward.  

As this study has already been approved by the DCU Ethics Committee, we would really value your participation and wider promotion of the research. We are aware that everyone is extremely busy at the moment but understanding educators’ experiences during these challenging times is more important than ever as we plan for the upcoming semester, and beyond. Therefore, please have your say by taking around 5 minutes to share your insights and valuable experiences through our anonymous survey.

You can read more about this research and complete the online survey after giving your informed consent by clicking on these embedded  links.